Was the climax of The Burning Sea of Iron Bottom Bay the most chaotic naval battle in history?
The climax of the young adult novel, The Burning Sea of Iron Bottom Bay, is referred to as “The Naval Battle of Guadalcanal.” It was fought on the night of Friday the 13th of November, 1942.
For sheer size, it’s not even close to the largest naval battle in history. In modern history, that title goes to either The WWI Battle of Jutland or the WWII Battle of Leyte Gulf (enthusiasts and historians argue that question to this day).
The Battle of Jutland included 250 ships. The Battle of Leyte Gulf involved more than 367 warships and submarines. Only two of the ships in the Naval Battle of Guadalcanal were what is commonly referred to as “capital ships.” Fifty-eight of the ships in The Battle of Jutland were of this massive type. Approximately 42 capital ships fought in The Battle of Leyte Gulf.
It’s important to remember that, by their very nature, battles are chaotic.
The quote, “No plan survives first contact with the enemy” is attributed to either Helmuth von Moltke in 1871 or to Prussian General Carl von Clausewitz. But certainly other officers have said essentially the same thing many times over. What then would give anyone the idea that the battle described in the climax of The Burning Sea of Iron Bottom Bay was, possibly, the most chaotic?
Modern naval battles are generally fought from a distance. Those capital ships, tossing shells that weigh almost as much as small cars, tens of miles, no longer, as in the Age of Sail, tie up to the enemy with the intent of boarding enemy ships. The fire power employed by modern warships of the 20th Century achieved a capacity that made close-quarter battles impractical. While you were trying to draw near to the enemy, they were pounding you with large, highly explosive penetrating shells and torpedoes from a distance.
When such a battle is cloaked in darkness, the chaos increases substantially. As happened in The Naval Battle of Guadalcanal, the chaos includes firing at friendly ships because you have trouble distinguishing friend form foe.
In The Naval Battle of Guadalcanal, darkness drew the opposing forces so close together that, at times, the Imperial Japanese Navy battlecruisers could not depress their guns low enough to fire at US Navy destroyers alongside. Ships of both sides were intermingled to the point that there was no longer two opposing forces.
Put it this way, many historians refer to the battle as a “barroom brawl.” Everyone was throwing punches and most were getting hit.